Supposedly Equivalent Facts That Aren't? Entity Frequency in Pre-training Induces Asymmetry in LLMs
Paper • 2503.22362 • Published
relation stringclasses 2
values | row_type stringclasses 1
value | subject stringlengths 3 9 | object stringlengths 3 9 | direction stringclasses 2
values | template_type stringclasses 2
values | alias_s stringlengths 2 167 | alias_o stringlengths 2 167 | demo_order_flipped bool 2
classes | prompt_hash stringlengths 12 12 | p_yes float64 0 0.99 | p_no float64 0 0.94 | yes_no_mass float64 0 1 | says_yes bool 2
classes | model_response stringclasses 13
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Great Alexander | Barsine | false | 1b5d3a6d9355 | 0.579173 | 0.385829 | 0.965002 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Great Alexander | Estatira | false | ae6bdece7336 | 0.642392 | 0.324771 | 0.967162 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Great Alexander | Stateira II | false | c6d4818a28c6 | 0.687597 | 0.279418 | 0.967015 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Great Alexander | Barsn | false | d7f3870184c1 | 0.406776 | 0.534039 | 0.940816 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Sikandar | Barsine | false | baf664ae83a3 | 0.64714 | 0.324224 | 0.971363 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Sikandar | Estatira | false | 96c233d583b1 | 0.624135 | 0.349237 | 0.973372 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Sikandar | Stateira II | false | 4aee4089f32f | 0.639466 | 0.32669 | 0.966155 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Sikandar | Barsn | false | c94df67f5498 | 0.575344 | 0.393439 | 0.968783 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander | Barsine | false | d4714f94648d | 0.600725 | 0.370973 | 0.971699 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander | Estatira | false | 0ffb2f5aa3d3 | 0.640536 | 0.335042 | 0.975578 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander | Stateira II | false | 8941a94f7917 | 0.669615 | 0.306264 | 0.975879 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander | Barsn | false | 6906cf1fae10 | 0.414825 | 0.540385 | 0.95521 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander The Great | Barsine | false | c50d998a3f4a | 0.529996 | 0.432799 | 0.962795 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander The Great | Estatira | false | c7c62f7621b6 | 0.438816 | 0.519122 | 0.957938 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander The Great | Stateira II | false | 6651a03cadf4 | 0.503744 | 0.459149 | 0.962892 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander The Great | Barsn | false | 13c44d5f9b40 | 0.247662 | 0.699139 | 0.946802 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Barsine | false | 119cb9893afe | 0.645045 | 0.325371 | 0.970416 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Estatira | false | b983ce3b7ac3 | 0.618951 | 0.347719 | 0.966669 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Stateira II | false | 8e6a1b2c9aad | 0.570287 | 0.395544 | 0.965831 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Barsn | false | f95419361793 | 0.54683 | 0.413989 | 0.960818 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander the great | Barsine | false | 9017cf1d5a41 | 0.501882 | 0.456414 | 0.958296 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander the great | Estatira | false | 195b929418be | 0.422369 | 0.531856 | 0.954225 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander the great | Stateira II | false | 126caa6f96f8 | 0.531668 | 0.430686 | 0.962355 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | forward | question | Alexander the great | Barsn | false | bcca732058b6 | 0.270531 | 0.677472 | 0.948003 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Great Alexander | Barsine | false | 43b8bbd021b2 | 0.543195 | 0.420543 | 0.963738 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Great Alexander | Estatira | false | 20375f863ba2 | 0.538812 | 0.417324 | 0.956135 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Great Alexander | Stateira II | false | 093ac9e20074 | 0.700975 | 0.266142 | 0.967118 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Great Alexander | Barsn | false | 4acded575ba2 | 0.479662 | 0.470474 | 0.950136 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Sikandar | Barsine | false | a142e24749b3 | 0.566726 | 0.40345 | 0.970176 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Sikandar | Estatira | false | 5a81fd2dfb5c | 0.583283 | 0.387878 | 0.971162 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Sikandar | Stateira II | false | 0e809a7c9fa9 | 0.650192 | 0.321051 | 0.971242 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Sikandar | Barsn | false | 0d78990747d4 | 0.512727 | 0.450523 | 0.963251 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander | Barsine | false | 4dfc1ca7cf1a | 0.51113 | 0.454465 | 0.965596 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander | Estatira | false | 9934ce9280e6 | 0.553187 | 0.415756 | 0.968942 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander | Stateira II | false | bb91e4dd6d48 | 0.6869 | 0.283903 | 0.970803 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander | Barsn | false | 970e0ac7fd77 | 0.435178 | 0.522426 | 0.957604 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander The Great | Barsine | false | 7f1082b32706 | 0.488748 | 0.472717 | 0.961465 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander The Great | Estatira | false | 6df09687da0f | 0.254964 | 0.68359 | 0.938553 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander The Great | Stateira II | false | 4f49fa5e4cb0 | 0.47445 | 0.47673 | 0.95118 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander The Great | Barsn | false | d54f04c9fb82 | 0.180374 | 0.76126 | 0.941634 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Barsine | false | 1d63cdf0c271 | 0.499593 | 0.469495 | 0.969087 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Estatira | false | ab7e0988ba4a | 0.486744 | 0.473902 | 0.960646 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Stateira II | false | 402e91b832c5 | 0.622824 | 0.343409 | 0.966233 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexandros III of Macedon | Barsn | false | 9ce8c30690aa | 0.294502 | 0.657486 | 0.951988 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander the great | Barsine | false | 1b98297f9378 | 0.472964 | 0.486107 | 0.959071 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander the great | Estatira | false | 14c6f141e552 | 0.258238 | 0.684324 | 0.942562 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander the great | Stateira II | false | 1df9d4520ebe | 0.516506 | 0.440695 | 0.957202 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q8409 | Q5429464 | backward | question | Alexander the great | Barsn | false | 6f8aa4ba3537 | 0.182616 | 0.760472 | 0.943088 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 5e5174dcba9c | 0.424009 | 0.540111 | 0.964121 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | a65a2ae8c719 | 0.381173 | 0.582755 | 0.963927 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | 92d755d3da46 | 0.410724 | 0.555312 | 0.966036 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Hatun | true | 3bd9cc9eb3b2 | 0.387557 | 0.57719 | 0.964746 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria | true | 143e57b48004 | 0.425512 | 0.548812 | 0.974324 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 1a79b2e67454 | 0.449356 | 0.516335 | 0.965691 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | ac19af8a9e08 | 0.45197 | 0.516958 | 0.968928 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 96216ed08994 | 0.518383 | 0.453572 | 0.971956 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | fb64bb60f669 | 0.523712 | 0.450768 | 0.97448 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Hatun | true | dc9ab38b8f0e | 0.512636 | 0.464701 | 0.977338 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria | true | 6509287c5e70 | 0.560657 | 0.417243 | 0.977901 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 13fca8d4abae | 0.5787 | 0.395926 | 0.974626 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 43245439c6fe | 0.438549 | 0.533912 | 0.972461 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 6c7a6052da08 | 0.497345 | 0.475246 | 0.972591 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | 0be7b487dc06 | 0.528393 | 0.449249 | 0.977642 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Hatun | true | 62475fead17f | 0.492263 | 0.486453 | 0.978717 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Maria | true | 49eabd61ba34 | 0.53866 | 0.440187 | 0.978847 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 789d5112da6d | 0.548407 | 0.426651 | 0.975058 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | cf20f30a1ddc | 0.454241 | 0.514721 | 0.968962 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | d81fbe617c40 | 0.414247 | 0.553233 | 0.96748 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | a9b831e0f694 | 0.502033 | 0.470095 | 0.972128 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Hatun | true | 1793b87e40a9 | 0.433307 | 0.536287 | 0.969594 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Maria | true | d081f06affb1 | 0.42286 | 0.551133 | 0.973993 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan Gazi | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | aca06256e9ba | 0.453015 | 0.513082 | 0.966097 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 3dbc2315a4a3 | 0.443961 | 0.519267 | 0.963228 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 6482cd583419 | 0.458307 | 0.508167 | 0.966474 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | bbeba8587624 | 0.469942 | 0.499601 | 0.969543 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Hatun | true | d7802268ae69 | 0.476136 | 0.495237 | 0.971373 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Maria | true | 1a0826f7748e | 0.538681 | 0.437654 | 0.976334 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orhan I | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 467ae42049d3 | 0.515733 | 0.453218 | 0.968951 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 65b239526f96 | 0.441083 | 0.524895 | 0.965977 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 6c3429c64da6 | 0.421227 | 0.545448 | 0.966675 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | a9220ea608cd | 0.419216 | 0.550219 | 0.969435 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Hatun | true | 14ae6f50d93f | 0.372401 | 0.6004 | 0.972801 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Maria | true | 59fc2d039f2c | 0.447386 | 0.526639 | 0.974025 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | forward | question | Orchan | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 3b76eab3daf4 | 0.404578 | 0.56379 | 0.968367 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 55f3d486659a | 0.427562 | 0.535465 | 0.963027 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 46959bb6755b | 0.35959 | 0.610949 | 0.970539 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | 25468c2b4531 | 0.359744 | 0.608663 | 0.968407 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Hatun | true | 7eea1d6029f3 | 0.359043 | 0.608162 | 0.967205 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria | true | 8009b7034bdc | 0.371451 | 0.598058 | 0.969508 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Ghazi | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | de453d1bb639 | 0.426131 | 0.538785 | 0.964916 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | 86ed3859e278 | 0.421386 | 0.54392 | 0.965306 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 2b70e74e0894 | 0.506102 | 0.467304 | 0.973406 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | 25915091a1d7 | 0.480002 | 0.491965 | 0.971966 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Hatun | true | b245656b4219 | 0.489051 | 0.484647 | 0.973698 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria | true | 55a4fdba8e3e | 0.455155 | 0.517331 | 0.972486 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan | Theodora Maria Hatun | true | 1e63be250b46 | 0.58626 | 0.384958 | 0.971218 | true | Yes |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Kantakouzene, wife of Orhan | true | f72516d59542 | 0.44621 | 0.519629 | 0.965839 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Maria Kantakouzene | true | 149854b9d476 | 0.428272 | 0.545395 | 0.973667 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Kantakouzene | true | 094094ab688b | 0.447723 | 0.527337 | 0.97506 | false | No |
P26 | true | Q133168 | Q12812195 | backward | question | Orhan Bey | Theodora Hatun | true | 88c47ec0b89c | 0.455978 | 0.520339 | 0.976317 | false | No |
Arm b2 of the FactProbe replication (He et al. arXiv:2503.22362): few-shot completion probing of the BASE OLMo-2-1124-7B final stage-1 checkpoint on symmetric-relation fact recognition (spouse P26, sibling P3373), forward and backward directions, all alias variations. One row per prompt; p_yes/p_no are next-token probability mass over Yes/No (question) or True/False (statement) single-token variants.
| Column | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| relation | Value('string') | Wikidata relation (P26 spouse / P3373 sibling) |
| row_type | Value('string') | 'true' (real pair) or 'scrambled_control' |
| subject | Value('string') | No description provided |
| object | Value('string') | No description provided |
| direction | Value('string') | forward = CSV (s,o) order; backward = reversed surface order |
| template_type | Value('string') | No description provided |
| alias_s | Value('string') | subject alias used in this prompt variation |
| alias_o | Value('string') | object alias used in this prompt variation |
| demo_order_flipped | Value('bool') | No description provided |
| prompt_hash | Value('string') | No description provided |
| p_yes | Value('float64') | next-token probability mass on Yes/True single-token variants |
| p_no | Value('float64') | next-token probability mass on No/False single-token variants |
| yes_no_mass | Value('float64') | p_yes + p_no (reliability screen; arm gate median >= 0.5) |
| says_yes | Value('bool') | p_yes > p_no for this prompt |
| model_response | Value('string') | argmax next token text (full, untruncated) |
{
"script_name": "score_b2.py",
"model": "allenai/OLMo-2-1124-7B @ stage1-step928646-tokens3896B (base, final stage-1)",
"description": "Arm b2 of the FactProbe replication (He et al. arXiv:2503.22362): few-shot completion probing of the BASE OLMo-2-1124-7B final stage-1 checkpoint on symmetric-relation fact recognition (spouse P26, sibling P3373), forward and backward directions, all alias variations. One row per prompt; p_yes/p_no are next-token probability mass over Yes/No (question) or True/False (statement) single-token variants.",
"hyperparameters": {
"temperature": 0.0,
"max_tokens": 1,
"logprobs_topk": 20,
"demos": "4 fictional-pair demonstrations, deterministic order flip"
},
"input_datasets": [
"Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.15092789 (FactProbe triples)"
],
"experiment_name": "factprobe-replication",
"job_id": "mll:65541",
"cluster": "mll",
"artifact_status": "final",
"canary": false
}
from datasets import load_dataset
dataset = load_dataset("latkes/factprobe-replication-b2-olmo7b-stage1-v1", split="train")
print(f"Loaded {len(dataset)} rows")